DMI Blog

Andrew Friedman

Immigration Blues

Over a year has passed since the massive immigrant rights rallies of last spring. Millions took to the streets throughout the country to demand fair treatment for immigrant workers and families. Last fall, the most anti-immigrant candidates were swept out of us. The Republicans lost their majority in both houses of Congress. President Bush really could not be less popular.

Nonetheless, the Democrats sure know how to snatch defeat from the jaws from the jaws of victory. Instead of using their new power and increasing popularity to push for comprehensive immigration reform, the Dems seem content to let the Republicans to determine the parameters of the debate.

What has been the Democrats bold, new move? They have re-introduced the bill that was passed by the Republican Senate last year! The bill was weak and ineffective last year. This year it is simply pathetic. It fails to resolve the problems of immigration - either for immigrants or for the country as a whole. It fails to bring families and workers out of the shadows, and it creates 3 tiers of immigrants, which arbitrarily assigns different rights to each tier.

So much for using their mandate.

In the face of Democratic weakness in Washington, the anti-immigrant crowd has been active. In yesterday's New York Times, there was an article about a Dallas suburb that voted to make renting to undocumented families illegal. Voters decided that concerns about discrimination and national origin discrimination could be set-aside, and people should police each other.

What a disgrace.

Posted by Andrew Friedman at May 14, 2007 08:12 AM

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
/cgi-bin/mt32/mt-tb.cgi/1036

Comments

Exactly. What a disgrace.

Posted by: Gonzalo Diaz | May 14, 2007 09:41 AM

Its been my experience that, without exception, everyone I've spoken with (by this time several hundreds of people) is opposed to any form of amnesty or guest worker policy. Indeed, the overwhelming majority of America's citizens (regardless of what skewed polling you choose to refute the fact) are against any increases in overall immigration numbers. Rather than try to support your untenable position by attributing it to "Democrats" letting the Republicans do their "dirty work", why not accept that this might actually be the result of our "democracy" working the way its supposed to? Maybe its simply a reflection or the "true" will of America's citizens? Perhaps its only that politicians are now actually getting enough "flack" from their constituents, that they may "fear" that passing this Administrations egregiously misguided comprehensive reforms, will result with voters putting these morons back on the street come 2008?

The fact that I haven't found anyone who supports amnesty or guest worker policies may be a reflection of the fact that I live in a border state, but given the diversity and cosmopolitan nature of the local population, I tend to think that this position may be more in keeping with the majority of Citizens than not.

Posted by: Ed Weirdness | May 14, 2007 09:42 AM

What a disgrace - the real disgrace is the corrupt government of Mexico that encourages its poor to illegally enter our country!! Why don't these illegals revolt against the Mexican billionaires that prefer to stuff their fat faces and don't give a hoot about their poor people? Too bad we don't have an ocean that separates us from that miserable excuse of a country!!
Illegals - go back home and fix the problems of your own country instead of creating problems for legal American citizens. Being able to swim the Rio Grande doesn't give you the right to chisel from hard working American citizens.

Posted by: Mary | May 14, 2007 09:29 PM

So, it seems plausible that the Democrats don't actually care to see a strong immigratation reform pass. Fair point.

The final comment, though, seems a bit off the chart. True, Mexico, like the U.S., is characterized by extreme economic inequality. Like here, it is disgusting, and many millions of people suffer the consequences. Our own government, and NAFTA, indubitable share culpability with the upper class in Mexico.

Mexico, though, is hardly a "miserable excuse of a country." Seeking opportunity by migrating to the United States seems to me a sensible decision.

The Mexican people, though, are moving left.

Posted by: Andrew Friedman | May 15, 2007 10:17 AM


Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)